Plea Bargain Considered; Cupp Waives Preliminary
by Nancy Henshaw Fuller, Staff Writer
7 years ago | 153 views | 0 0 comments | 0 0 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Following a lengthy negotiation period on Monday,

Assistant District Attorney Diana Reynolds Clayton offered a plea agreement to accused racketeer and embezzler Donna Cupp, 48, former Central School superintendent.

Cupp, represented by Stilwell attorney Todd Hembree, responded to the offer by filing a waiver of a preliminary hearing, which was scheduled for 9 a.m., records show.

By waiving her preliminary hearing, Cupp indicated her intent to accept the plea bargain offered by Clayton. Also, by waiving the preliminary hearing, Cupp gave up her right to make the state prove its case against her, Clayton said.

The plea agreement said Cupp would plead guilty to one count of racketeering, one count of embezzlement, two counts of erasure or obliteration of an instrument, and one count of obtaining property by deception.

For that guilty plea, Cupp will receive a five-year suspended sentence; she will pay restitution of $164,000 (including the school's attorney and audit fees), $100,000 of that amount must be paid within 30 days; she will permanently surrender her professional license; and Cupp and the school agree to resolving all pending civil charges with 30 days. Clayton said Cupp must borrow the full amount from a bank and pay the school in the next 30 days or face an asset hearing in which her property may be evaluated.

List of Charges


In count one, Cupp is accused of converting school funds to her own use by approving requisitions and purchase orders to the vendors from whom she bought various articles of home furnishings and equipment in an amount exceeding $45,000.

Cupp is accused of forging the signature of Principal Curtis Moore, second co-signer required by the school for disbursement of school funds. She then allegedly converted more than $68,000 to her own use.

In count two Cupp is accused of depositing a $26,366.60 insurance check made out to the school into her own account.

In counts three and four Cupp is accused of the erasure or obliteration of bank statements; creating and uttering forged checks; and embezzled cash from various deposits intended for the Central Public Schools Activity Fund Account.

In count five Cupp is accused of obtaining property by trick or deception by providing a false purchase order number, securing the tax-exempt status to which the school is entitled.

Special District Judge Dennis Sprouse set an arraignment date for Cupp at 1:30 p.m. March 25 before District Judge John C. Garrett.

Cupp Receives Mental Evaluation


Cupp's preliminary hearing was delayed last year so she could receive a court-ordered competency evaluation at the Oklahoma Forensic Center in Vinita. Judged competent to assist with her defense, the preliminary hearing can now be held.

Cupp was charged in August 2002 with the embezzlement of about $140,000 from the Central School Activity Account.

Cupp was fired from Central in July 2002, and is accused of spending most of the money on personal and household items for a new home she built on South Dogwood in Sallisaw, records show.

The Oklahoma State Auditor's office in Oklahoma City began an audit in June 2002 after being contacted by the school after the discovery that funds were missing.

After an experiment that lasted several months, the editors at Your TIMES decided this week to end the practice of allowing anonymous comments on our website because most of the comments involve personal attacks and unfounded accusations. These comments do not add information to a story, or add any true insight. While we believe in the free exchange of ideas, it had become evident that was not what was happening in the comment section of our website. Readers can also become fans of Your TIMES on Facebook and may comment on our postings there. Readers are also encouraged to write letters to the editor to the newspaper about matters of public interest. The newspaper circulation is several times that of the web site, so readership is much higher. Letters must include a name and phone number so that we may contact the writer to verify authenticity of the letter. Letters are limited to 500 words and one letter per writer per month is accepted.