Charges stand in abuse case
5 years ago | 45 views | 0 0 comments | 2 2 recommendations | email to a friend | print
A Muskogee County judge decided Wednesday that charges against a Braggs area woman accused of child abuse will not be dismissed, despite defense arguments that prosecutors have failed to provide the woman with a speedy trial.

Melanie Smith, 25, was charged last year with starving and abusing her 4-year-old son, who was discovered malnourished and bruised from head to toe at a Gore home.

A jury trial for Smith has been set twice in recent months, but both times the trials were postponed.

Smith's attorney filed a motion last month asking the court to dismiss the charges, based on Smith's right to a speedy trial. Prosecutors argued Wednesday that the delays were not deliberate. A judge on Wednesday agreed, citing that the only issue is if the delays have impaired the defense, which the judge said has not been proven by the defense.

Three others are charged in the case, including Smith's half-brother, Roy Albert Smith, 21, of the Braggs area who has been free on $20,000 bond since November. He is set to appear in Muskogee County court on Sept. 29.

Child abuse charges are also pending in Sequoyah County against Gore women, Brenna Ann Smith, 30, and Sharon Kay Smith, 50. Brenna and Sharon Smith reportedly cared for the boy while Melanie and Roy Smith were at work. Charges against the two, who were bound over in September 2005, are pending.

A tip about the alleged abuse of the boy led to an investigation by the Department of Human Services (DHS), who then contacted Gore police. Officers found the boy in Sharon Kay Smith's Gore home. Police reported that the boy could barely walk when he was first found.

After an experiment that lasted several months, the editors at Your TIMES decided this week to end the practice of allowing anonymous comments on our website because most of the comments involve personal attacks and unfounded accusations. These comments do not add information to a story, or add any true insight. While we believe in the free exchange of ideas, it had become evident that was not what was happening in the comment section of our website. Readers can also become fans of Your TIMES on Facebook and may comment on our postings there. Readers are also encouraged to write letters to the editor to the newspaper about matters of public interest. The newspaper circulation is several times that of the web site, so readership is much higher. Letters must include a name and phone number so that we may contact the writer to verify authenticity of the letter. Letters are limited to 500 words and one letter per writer per month is accepted.